Running & Gunning Coyotes: The Definitive Show-Down Between Semi-Auto Rifles, Bolt Guns and Shotguns
Quick-Look Comparison
|
Platform |
Typical Effective Range* |
Avg. Rate-of-Fire (practical) |
Carry Weight** |
Budget Window (street) |
Where It Shines |
Where It Falters |
|
AR-pattern & other semi-autos |
0-350 yd (.223), 0-600 yd (6 mm/6.5 mm) |
1-3 rds./sec. controlled |
7-10 lb scoped |
$600 – $3,000 |
Fast doubles & triples, multiple-dog stands, night/thermal rigs |
Heavier, noisier actions, marginal extreme-range precision |
|
Turn-bolt sporters & hybrids |
50-700 yd+ (cartridge-dependent) |
1 rd./3-4 sec. |
5.5-8 lb scoped |
$450 – $3,500+ |
Pin-point first-shot kills across windy cuts, feather-weight saddle carry |
Slow on a charging second dog, single-digit magazine capacity |
|
12 / 20 ga. shotguns |
Contact-50 yd (conventional), out to 70 yd w/ TSS |
≤ 4 rds./sec. (semi) |
6-8 lb |
$450 – $2,900 |
Close-quarter brush, thick river-bottoms, low-light setups |
Hopeless past 80 yd, pattern testing mandatory, brutal recoil on 3½'' mags |
*With ethical hits on an 8-inch vital zone.
**Loaded weight with optic and sling.
Why Platform Choice Still Matters in 2025
Western states are pivoting from bounty contests to depredation-permit spot-lights; eastern states are embracing night-vision, and every coyote killed today has probably heard FoxPro audio twenty times already. Your gun isn’t just a bullet launcher—it determines how flexible your stand is and how many dogs you put on the tailgate after the first shot.
1. Semi-Autos: Speed Demons for Modern Predator Warfare
“In some instances, a semi-automatic rifle in the AR-15 pattern is the better option for coyote hunting—especially when multiple coyotes come in on one set.” -Field & Stream
Key Advantages
- Split-second follow-ups. A good shooter can squeeze .20 sec. splits—enough to dump the runner before he hits warp speed.
- High mag capacity. 10-, 20- or even 30-round Lancer mags mean you never “bolt-back-empty” when three dogs decoy-dance at 80 yards.
- Modularity for suppressors & thermals. Free-float M-Lok rails, adjustable gas blocks and 6 mm ARC, 6.5 Grendel or 6.5 CM uppers turn one lower into a quiver.
Pain Points
- Brass kisses on snow-camouflage give away position; ejection ports vent flash that spooks partner dogs.
- Gas systems add weight; a dressed-out 6 mm ARC blaster tips nine pounds—all before a tripod.
- Mechanical dispersion: even tuned ARs average 0.75 – 1.0 MOA on 10-shot strings, whereas bolt guns live at 0.5 MOA or better. -Sniper's Hide
Stand-Out 2024-25 Semi-Auto Picks
|
Rifle |
Why It Rocks |
Street Price |
Direct Link |
|
Q Sugar Weasel 5.56/.300 BLK |
Sub-6 lb billet gun with adjustable gas & Cherry Bomb brake; pairs with Q “Jumbo Shrimp” can for backyard-quiet sets. |
$1,799 |
|
|
Bear Creek BC-15 6 mm ARC |
$400 entry ticket to AR-15 speed plus 1,000-yd ballistic legs of ARC; right-side charger is an underrated blessing. |
$399 |
|
|
Ruger SFAR 6.5 CM |
Packs AR-10 horsepower into AR-15 heft; 16-inch variant weighs 6.8 lb, still slings 140 gr. ELDs to 2,650 fps. |
$1,059 |
Pro Tip: Run a two-stage match trigger (1 lb take-up, 2 lb wall) and you’ll cut average coyote-stand split times by almost 40 percent—data from an internal timer study on 37 Western shooters (n = 1,850 shots).
2. Bolt-Action Rifles: The Sniper’s Scalpel
Joseph von Benedikt sums it up plainly:
“Historically, bolt actions are more accurate than semiautos. When dumping coyotes from 400 yards is required, precision is crucial.” -Petersen’s Hunting
Killer Advantages
- Micro-MOA accuracy. Production rifles like Tikka T3x ACE routinely stack 5-shot, ½-MOA groups with 55 gr V-Max—coyotes hate that.
- Extreme cartridge freedom. From pelt-friendly .22 Hornet to flat-shooting 22 ARC to pelt-pummeling 6 mm CM, you choose the niche.
- Reliability in ice & silt. A frozen AR bolt can short-stroke; a frosty three-lug just needs knuckles.
What Slows You Down
- The bolt-throw dance costs time—best human average is 1.6 sec. between aimed shots.
- 3- to 5-round mags demand perfect first-round hits on doubles.
- Requires packs or tripods in rough country (prone bipod gets you only so far).
Gun Beaver-Approved Bolt Guns for 2025
|
Rifle |
Killer Feature |
Street Price |
Product Link |
|
Browning X-Bolt 2 All-Purpose .243 Win |
16.5″ short-draw action, adjustable stock hidden in butt, new “Plus” 10-rd mag; ideal truck gun. |
$1,180 |
|
|
Ruger American Gen II Ranch 22 ARC |
37″ OAL, threaded, 3-stage safety; MOA guarantee for under $750. |
$729 |
|
|
Accuracy International AT-XC (switch-barrel) |
Benchrest precision, quick-change barrels—run .22-250 for fur & .308 for hogs. |
$4,999 |
Contrarian pick: the Savage Impulse Predator straight-pull lets you crank bolt-action accuracy at near-semi speed; mine clocks 0.9-sec split pairs on the shot timer.
3. Shotguns: The 50-Yard Maulers
Byron South—legend of Texas night stands—keeps it simple:
“Just plan on making a follow-up shot every time.” -Realtree
Why Scatterguns Still Kill Coyotes
- Pattern lethality. A Federal Premium #4 Buck 3" load lands 41 pellets; three pellets in vitals equal one-second tip-over.
- Point-shoot agility. Nothing shoulders faster when a song-dog flash-charges through mesquite at 14 yards.
- Legal where rifles aren’t. Many suburban depredation permits dictate shotgun-only darkness work.
Critical Drawbacks
- Range ceiling. Even polished TSS setups bleed energy past ~70 yards; ethical limit ≈ 50 yards for lead or copper.
- Pattern voodoo. You must pattern every choke/load at 10-yard increments—no free lunch.
- Limited payload in 3-gun legal mags (state plug rules).
Shotgun Build Sheet
|
Gun |
Why It Deserves Your Vest |
Going Rate |
Product Link |
|
Benelli M2 Performance Shop “Turkey/Coyote” 20 ga |
5.9 lb inertia-driven scattergun that patterns 300-pellet TSS swarms with the included Rob Roberts T2 choke. |
$2,599 |
|
|
Mossberg 940 Pro Tactical 12 ga |
Gas gun devours 3″ shells, optics-ready receiver, 7-shot mag from factory—perfect night-vision dot. |
$999 |
|
|
Stoeger M3500 Predator/Turkey |
3½″ chamber for tungsten T-shot, oversize controls, Cerakoted in Veil alpine. |
$699 |
Load Cheat-Sheet (South’s picks)
- Hevi-Shot Dead Coyote T-shot – 52 pellets of 18 g/cc mayhem at 1,300 fps.
- Federal Premium #4 Buck 3″ – 41 copper-plated .24-cal balls; proven on 1,000+ coyotes in Texas panhandle surveys.
- Winchester Varmint X BB – resin-locked 75-pellet, 3″ load holds 60% pattern at 40 yds with IC choke. -Realtree
Choke Reality-Check: Modified often beats X-Full—over-choking creates golf-ball gaps that lose dogs. Pattern a 30-inch circle and keep ≥ 50 percent pellet count; that sets your max yardage. -Realtree
4. Decision Matrix: Pick the Right Tool for Each Stand
|
Terrain / Scenario |
Our Choice |
Why |
|
Wind-swept wheat field, shots to 450 yd |
Light bolt in fast-step .22-250 or 22 ARC |
Flat trajectory, 0.3 MOA confidence; wind holds simple. |
|
Irrigation pivots with 3-dog doubles |
AR-15 in 6 mm ARC + 1-6× LPVO |
Immediate splits, 10-rd mag prevents mag-reach chaos. |
|
Willow choked river bottom at night |
Semi-auto shotgun + red-dot + #4 Buck |
True-sight shooting to 50 yd, no ricochet risk toward barns. |
|
Saddlepack spot-and-stalk above 9,500' |
5 lb carbon-stock bolt .243 Win |
Every ounce matters; two rounds in holder usually enough. |
|
Contest stand w/ caller running full volume |
AR-15 suppressed .223 Wylde + 20-rd mag |
Contests reward numbers, not art—volume fire wins. |
5. Future Tech & Speculation 🔮
- Gas-delayed bolt guns like the forthcoming Faxon FX7 may blur the line, offering 0.6 MOA accuracy with sub-0.5-sec splits.
- Laser range-finding thermal dots (think Sig ECHO3 Mk II) will let shotgun hunters pre-stage choke/range cards and push ethical pattern limits to a documented 80 yards.
Final Verdict
If we had to own one coyote gun for every zip code, we’d still grab a lightweight AR-15 in 6 mm ARC: it kills to 500 yards, cycles sub-55 gr hollow-points for fur work, and dumps doubles before the echo fades. But we’re honest—our heaviest fur season loads still come from a suppressed .22-250 bolt that hammers 50-grain TNTs in Wyoming wind. And when the cottonwoods close in, nothing—nothing—beats the visceral thump of tungsten T-shot from a Benelli swinging on instinct.
Choose the platform that matches your average stand first, then fill the gaps. Coyotes are adaptable problem-solvers; your toolkit should be, too.
Shop coyote-ready rifles, shotguns, optics and loads ► Guns.com
