Benelli M4 vs. M2: Unveiling the Key Differences That Set These Tactical Shotguns Apart

In the world of tactical shotguns, few names command the respect and admiration of both professionals and enthusiasts like Benelli. Renowned for their precision engineering, durability, and innovative design, Benelli shotguns are a trusted choice for military, law enforcement, and civilian users. Among their celebrated lineup, the Benelli M4 and Benelli M2 frequently dominate conversations. While both models share the brand’s commitment to excellence, their features and functionalities differ in ways that make them uniquely suited to distinct roles and users.

In this detailed comparison, we’ll uncover what makes the Benelli M4 unique and how it stacks up against its sibling, the Benelli M2. Whether you’re in the market for a tactical shotgun or a versatile field companion, this guide will help you make an informed decision.

1. Benelli M4: Built for Tactical Excellence

The Benelli M4 is a semi-automatic shotgun designed with military applications in mind. Introduced in 1998, it quickly gained prominence after being adopted by the U.S. Marine Corps under the designation M1014 Combat Shotgun.

Key Features of the Benelli M4

• Auto-Regulating Gas-Operated (ARGO) System
  At the heart of the M4 is Benelli’s patented ARGO system, a revolutionary gas-operated mechanism. Unlike traditional gas systems, ARGO uses twin stainless-steel pistons mounted close to the chamber, which reduces fouling and ensures consistent performance under extreme conditions.
• Durable Construction
  Built for the rigors of combat, the M4 features a corrosion-resistant steel barrel and an anodized aluminum receiver. These materials ensure longevity and reliability, even in harsh environments.
• Picatinny Rail
  The integrated Picatinny rail allows for easy mounting of optics and accessories, enhancing the shotgun’s tactical versatility.
• Adjustable Stock Options
  The M4 comes with several stock configurations, including a collapsible stock and a fixed pistol grip stock, catering to different ergonomic preferences.
• Capacity and Compatibility
  The standard magazine holds 5+1 rounds, but it can be upgraded to 7+1 rounds with an extended magazine tube. Additionally, the M4 is compatible with a wide range of aftermarket parts.

Ideal Applications for the Benelli M4

• Military and law enforcement operations
• Home defense
• Tactical competitions

2. Benelli M2: Versatility Meets Performance

The Benelli M2 is a lightweight, semi-automatic shotgun designed for versatility. Known for its speed and reliability, the M2 excels in field applications, from hunting to competitive shooting.

Key Features of the Benelli M2

• Inertia-Driven System
  Unlike the gas-operated M4, the M2 uses Benelli’s Inertia-Driven System, which relies on recoil energy to cycle the action. This design minimizes weight and ensures cleaner operation, as fewer gases are vented into the mechanism.
• Lightweight Design
  Weighing around 6.7 to 7.2 pounds (depending on configuration), the M2 is significantly lighter than the M4, making it ideal for extended use in the field.
• Cryogenically Treated Barrel
  The M2’s barrel undergoes cryogenic treatment, which improves accuracy and extends the barrel’s lifespan.
• Comfortech Stock System
  Benelli’s proprietary Comfortech stock reduces felt recoil by up to 48%, enhancing shooter comfort during high-volume shooting sessions.
• Wide Range of Configurations
  Available in field, tactical, and turkey-specific configurations, the M2 caters to a variety of shooting disciplines.

Ideal Applications for the Benelli M2

• Hunting (waterfowl, turkey, and upland game)
• Sporting clays and other shooting sports
• Home defense

3. Comparing the Benelli M4 and M2

While both shotguns share Benelli’s legendary craftsmanship, their differences make them uniquely suited to different tasks.

4. Key Factors to Consider When Choosing
5. Intended Use

• The Benelli M4 is ideal for tactical scenarios requiring reliability in high-stress environments.
• The Benelli M2 is a versatile all-rounder, excelling in hunting and competitive shooting.

2. Weight and Recoil

• If you prioritize a lightweight shotgun with reduced recoil, the M2 is the clear winner.
• For those willing to trade a bit of weight for rugged durability, the M4 is the better option.

3. Maintenance and Cleanliness

• The Inertia-Driven System of the M2 is easier to clean and maintain, making it preferable for field use.
• The ARGO System of the M4, while slightly more complex, offers unparalleled reliability in tactical situations.

4. Budget

• The M4’s advanced features come at a higher price point, while the M2 offers excellent performance at a slightly lower cost.

5. Popular Models and Variants

Benelli M4 Variants

• Benelli M4 Tactical
  The flagship model with a Picatinny rail, ghost ring sights, and a fixed stock.
• Benelli M4 H2O Tactical
  Features a Cerakote finish for enhanced corrosion resistance, perfect for maritime environments.

Benelli M2 Variants

• Benelli M2 Field
  A lightweight option tailored for hunting and sporting.
• Benelli M2 Tactical
  Combines the M2’s inertia-driven performance with tactical features like ghost ring sights and an extended magazine tube.

6. Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can the Benelli M4 be used for hunting?
A: While the M4 is primarily designed for tactical use, it can be adapted for hunting with the right configurations. However, its heavier weight and gas system may not be ideal for prolonged field use.

Q: Is the Benelli M2 suitable for home defense?
A: Absolutely. The M2’s lightweight design and fast cycling make it an excellent choice for home defense scenarios.

Q: Which shotgun has better aftermarket support?
A: The M4 offers greater customization options, with a wide array of aftermarket parts available for tactical enhancements.

7. Final Thoughts: Which Shotgun Is Right for You?

Choosing between the Benelli M4 and M2 boils down to your specific needs and preferences. If you’re looking for a combat-ready shotgun with unmatched reliability, the M4 is your go-to. For those who need a versatile and lightweight option for hunting, sport, or home defense, the M2 shines as a dependable choice.

Both shotguns uphold Benelli’s reputation for excellence, ensuring that whatever your decision, you’ll own a firearm that delivers superior performance and reliability.

Shop Now

Ready to choose your next Benelli shotgun? Check out Guns.com full range of Benelli M4 and M2 shotguns and find the perfect fit for your needs!